What a mark assumes
A portfolio view multiplies what you hold by the last price. For a small holding in a deep market that is close enough to the truth. For a fixed-yield position of real size it describes something else: what the position would be worth if someone were willing to buy all of it at that price, now.
Nobody has promised that. On-chain, the buyer is usually a pool, and a pool quotes a worse price for each additional unit sold into it. The mark tells you where the market is. It says nothing about what you would receive.
What an exit costs
Exit cost is the difference between the marked value of a position and what you would receive for it if you left today. It has four parts.
- Price impact. Your own sale moves the price against you.
- Fees. The pool's swap fee and the network cost of each transaction.
- The route. A principal token is rarely the last step. It is sold for the yield-bearing token underneath, which is then sold or redeemed for a plain stablecoin. Each leg has its own depth.
- Time. Some redemptions settle in hours or days. A delay is a cost, because the price can move while you wait.
Principal tokens add one more point. They redeem at face value only at maturity. Before that date the way out is to sell.
Why rules of thumb miss
The common shortcut divides the size of the sale by the size of the pool and calls the result the cost. Pools for fixed-yield tokens are not built that way. Their liquidity is concentrated around the price the token is expected to trade at, so the cost stays low across a range of sizes and then climbs quickly once a sale pushes past that range.
- AA small share of the depth. The cost stays low.
- BA large share. The cost climbs faster than the shortcut suggests.
The shortcut can miss by a wide margin in either direction. The figure worth trusting is a quote for your actual size along your actual route.
Depth is not a constant
A quote is true for the moment it is taken. Liquidity providers can withdraw, and they tend to do so in the same hours that holders want to sell. A position that was a small share of the depth last week can be a large share of it today.
A position can become hard to leave without changing at all.
Two things follow. Exit cost has to be read continuously, not once at entry. And the cost alone is not enough: you also need your share of what is there. A holder who needs 3% of the available depth and one who needs a third of it are in different positions, however similar their marks look.
What size does not fix
Keeping a position small against the depth is the most direct way to hold exit cost down. It is worth being clear about what it leaves untouched.
- Redemption. If the token underneath redeems on a delay, a small holder waits as long as a large one.
- Control. If an administrator can pause withdrawals or set the token's price, every holder is exposed in proportion.
We treat these as three separate questions: what selling would cost, how redemption works, and who can change the rules. Sizing answers only the first.
Questions to ask of any position
- If I left today, what would I receive for my full size, along the whole route to dollars?
- What share of the available depth would I need?
- What would the same exit cost with less depth in the pool?
- How far am I willing to let that cost go, and how close is it now?
- If selling is not possible, how does redemption work and how long does it take?
None of these needs a forecast. Each can be measured today. We measure them before entering a market and keep measuring while we hold it.
For information only. This note is not investment advice, an offer or a solicitation.